LMS requirements checklist and vendor scorecard (free Excel)
Write your LMS requirements once, send the same list to every vendor, and compare their answers on one sheet. Mark each requirement as must-have, important or nice-to-have, score each vendor from 0 to 3, and the workbook ranks them, flagging any vendor that misses a must-have.
The eight areas it covers
- Courses and content: SCORM, xAPI, cmi5, video, documents, course builder
- Assessments: quizzes, question banks, assignments, grading, certificates
- Learners: enrolment, paths, mobile, languages, accessibility
- Administration: roles, groups, bulk import, notifications, branding
- Reporting: progress, completion, compliance, exports, dashboards
- Integrations and sign-in: SSO, user provisioning, HR, video meetings, APIs
- Selling courses: checkout, payment gateways, coupons, tax invoices
- Security, data and cost: hosting, data ownership, exit plan, total cost
What’s in the file
Requirements
60 requirements written so a vendor can answer yes, partly or no, with a column for the evidence you want to see in the demo.
Weighting
Must-have (weight 5), important (3) or nice-to-have (1). Change weights to suit your team.
Vendor scorecard
Score up to four vendors from 0 to 3. Totals, percentages and rank calculate automatically, and any vendor scoring 0 on a must-have is flagged.
Summary
Each vendor’s score by area side by side, with a chart, ready to put in front of whoever approves the budget.
How to use it
- Delete requirements you don’t need and add any that are specific to you. Ten sharp must-haves beat 60 vague ones.
- Set the priority for each one before you talk to vendors, so the weighting isn’t bent to fit a favourite.
- Send the list to vendors and ask them to answer in writing, then check the claims in the demo.
- Score each vendor on the Scorecard sheet. Read the must-have flags before you read the totals.
Questions
Can I use this as an LMS RFP template?
Yes. The requirements sheet is designed to be sent to vendors as the requirements section of an RFP. Add your organisation’s background, timeline and commercial terms around it.
Why only 60 requirements?
Because long lists get copy-paste answers. Every vendor says yes to 300 generic lines. Sixty specific ones, trimmed further to your needs, force real answers.
Is it only for corporate training?
No. It works for training companies, coaching institutes, schools and anyone selling courses. Remove the areas you don’t need, such as selling courses if you only train staff.
Does it include self-hosted options?
Yes. The last area asks where the LMS runs, who owns the data, how you export it and what it costs over several years, which is where SaaS and self-hosted LMSs differ most.
When the spreadsheet stops being enough
Cloudgramam LMS is a self-hosted LMS licensed per domain. Score it with this sheet alongside everyone else.
See Cloudgramam LMS →